Referee reports on PRB submission BG14421

Thermodynamic inconsistency of the conventional theory of superconductivity

Submission
Referee 1 first report         Response to referee 1 first report
Referee 2 report         Response to referee 2 report
Editor decision 1         Response to Editor decision 1

Referee 1 second report         Response to referee 1 second report
Referee 3 report         Response to referee 3 report
Editor decision 2         Response to Editor decision 2

Auhor's appeal         EBM's appeal response
Editor decision 3         Response to Editor decision 3
Editor decision 4         Response to Editor decision 4

Auhor's appeal to Editor in Chief         EIC's appeal response

Subsequently, the paper was submitted to Journal of Physics Condensed Matter

Submission
Referee report         Editorial decision

Subsequently, the paper was submitted to International Journal of Modern Physics B

Submission
Referee 1 report         Editor's first decision         Response to referee 1 report

The paper was sent out for further review, and was accepted for publication on April 21.
Editorial decision

The final version of the paper to be published in IJMPB is given below.
Thermodynamic inconsistency of the conventional theory of superconductivity