Submission 9/20/2018
Referee 1 report
Editor decision 1
Response to referee1
Referee 2 report
Referee 3 report
Editor decision 2
Response to Editor decision 2
There was no response from the Editor to my Response to Editor decision 2.
Subsequently, the paper was submitted to Annalen der Physik on 1/6/2020
Response from AdP
Response to AdP
Subsequently, the paper was submitted to European Journal of Physics B on 1/7/2020
Reports from two EJPB referees
Subsequently, the paper was submitted to Physical Review X on 2/27/2020
Response from PRX editor
Subsequently, the paper was submitted to Modern Physics Letters B on 3/3/2020
Upon positive reviews from two referees, the paper was accepted
for publication on 4/17/2020
Published version